Select Page

PennyLick Ice Cream

Last week on a run to the post office, I searched “ice cream” to see if we could grab some treats on the way home. Since I leave my map search set to “open now” and for once we were out during normal human waking hours, a new place popped up: Pennylick Ice Cream.

TBH, they had me at hello 😜

The shop itself is small, with no seating inside, but there are two benches outside to enjoy your treats if the weather is nice, or you’re feeling your best polar bear self.

Their mission is to bring us the best, simplest ice cream flavors. Their site promises “dairy from local cows treated ethically, sustainable whole food ingredients, and no artificial flavors or colors.” Which means their mint chip is NOT green! That gets an extra point in our book. Kali especially dislikes green mint ice cream. Call it a quirk? Whatever. It’s not an issue here! Woooooo!

The flavors change up often as the ice cream is made in small batches so take a peek at the site before you head over! Our faves so far are Sophisticated S’mores & Aloha Coffee. A single scoop is pretty generous and will only set you back $4. There are also takeaway pints for $9 in case you’re feeling generous and want to share.

Interesting Flavors alongside the classics

Masks are required at all times. You can sample any flavors you’d like, but you do have to step outside to remove your mask. The staff was thorough in explaining this policy as they took Kali’s delighted OhMyGawd as incredulity. They were friendly but firm. Which was much appreciated. Once we explained that OMG was an exclamation of happiness re: the cleanliness of this ice cream parlor, we had a nice chat about COVID safety and ServSafe practices.

Scoops in hand, we had to get far from humans to dig in! We usually head to the Old Croton Aqueduct a short drive away so we can stroll and eat to burn off a couple cals from these frozen treats.

Now to get 6 feet from humans so we can dig in!

Devils & Details 😈


Good To Go! A tiny shop in the town center offering amazing handmade ice cream flavors, served with stellar COVID cleanliness practices by folks who are excited about ice cream as we are. We vote GO πŸ‘

Flavor Selection
Toppings & Fun Stuff
Scoop Size
Staff Awesomeness
COVID Safety

Join the discussion!

For the ‘gram


πŸ‘€ The Legal Stuff πŸ‘€

*These are affiliate links, from which we may receive a small commission if you make a purchase. It won’t cost you a penny extra, and it helps us keep the site up and running!